Home Insurance Going Up? How NEPA Buyers and Homeowners Can Push Back
Updated: 5 days ago

If you've opened a renewal notice lately and felt your stomach drop, you're not alone. Home insurance has become one of the biggest surprises in the monthly payment, for buyers working out a budget and for homeowners who've been in their homes for years.
Here's the honest picture, plus some good news.
Insurance is a bigger slice of the payment than it used to be
According to Intercontinental Exchange (ICE), the average mortgage holder now pays a record $209 a month for property insurance. That's about 9.6% of the average monthly mortgage payment, and nearly 80% more than at the start of 2020.
The good news: increases are slowing down
ICE reports that premiums rose 1.8% in the second quarter of 2026. That's the smallest quarterly gain since they started tracking it, and it's down from 4.3% in a single quarter back in mid-2024. Your premium will probably still creep up over time, just not as quickly as it did a couple of years ago.
Shopping around really pays
This is the part I want every client to hear. ICE found that homeowners who switched insurance companies cut their premiums by 6.6% on average. Those who stayed put saw a 10.4% increase. That's about $440 a year in savings, and the people who switched actually ended up with slightly lower deductibles and higher coverage limits.
What this means here in Clarks Summit, Scranton, and Olyphant
So many of the homes we love in Lackawanna County have some age and character to them. That charm is wonderful, but insurers look closely at things like the age of the roof, the heating system, the electrical, and the plumbing. Here's what I tell my buyers and sellers:
Buyers: Get insurance quotes early, ideally once you're under contract and before your inspection window closes. A quote can flag issues like an older roof that's worth negotiating on.
Get more than one quote. Talk to a local independent agent and at least one or two other carriers. Ask about bundling with your auto policy and discounts for things like security systems or updated systems in the home.
Homeowners: Don't auto-renew without looking. Treat your renewal date like a yearly checkup and compare at least a couple of options.
Sellers: Updates to the roof, furnace, or electrical don't just help you sell. They can make your home easier and cheaper for the next owner to insure, and that's a real selling point.
Insurance is one of those costs that's easy to forget about until it shows up in the escrow line. A little homework up front can keep more money in your pocket every single month.
Let's talk it through
Thinking about buying or selling and want to see what your full monthly payment might really look like, insurance included? Call or text me at (631) 357-1463. You can also explore what it's like to live and buy in Clarks Summit and Scranton, browse my Real Estate FAQ, or check out Buyer Coach if you're just starting to plan.
Keeping up with repairs matters too. Here's why you shouldn't wait on deferred maintenance.
Warmly,
Jillian Kemmerer
Associate Broker & Co-Owner, Realtor®
Source: ICE Mortgage Monitor, September 2026.



Comments